25 Metros Where Renters Are The Most Overextended

Photo Illustration by Stacker // Canva

Belong examined Census Bureau data to see which metros have renters who are putting the largest share of their income toward rent.

25 metros where renters are the most overextended

Anyone who has recently gone hunting for a new apartment to rent in a major city experiences the same headache. It seems like every year, rent prices go up while availability goes down.

Renters aren't just imagining this: From about 2010 to 2019, average rent for apartments across the U.S. has increased by around 2 to 5% annually, with a massive dip, followed by a surge, once the COVID-19 pandemic hit. From 2020 to 2022 alone, rent prices increased by 15%.

At the same time, wages have remained mostly stagnant. This has led to an affordability crisis: Many renters are familiar with the traditional recommendation of paying no more than 30% of a person's income in rent, but as prices go up while salaries stay the same, this may no longer be feasible for many.

Belong examined Census Bureau data to see where renters are putting the largest share of their income toward rent. Metros are ranked by the median gross rent as a percentage of household income. In the event of a tie, the share of renter-occupied homes in that metro were used.

Some areas have been hit harder than others. For instance, many of the listed cities are home to prominent universities and colleges, where there is high competition for limited units, causing a spike in rent.

Additionally, cities in the Sun Belt—including those in Florida, Texas, and other Southern states—experienced rent surges during the onset of the pandemic, when many workers left cities in colder climates to work remotely in sunnier areas. As a result, as many as 70% of apartments being built to fill demand in those areas are luxury units, with enviable amenities such as rooftop pools, on-premises spas, and coworking spaces.

Thankfully, the skyrocketing rates are thought to finally be cooling down a bit, at least in part due to increased housing availability. Nearly 1 million new apartments are currently being constructed across the country, popping up at the highest rate in 50 years. If this trend continues, renters may be able to let their wallets breathe a little more in the coming years.

YOUR GUIDE TO PROPERTY MANAGEMENT

Explore a comprehensive property management blog that covers tips, trends, and stories related to long-term renting, home renovation, and more.

B Brown // Shutterstock

#25. Rexburg, Idaho

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.2%
- Median rent: $849
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 6,274 (40.3%) of all housing units.

Canva

#24. Nacogdoches, Texas

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.2%
- Median rent: $812
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 10,205 (42.2%) of all housing units.

Canva

#23. Sebastian, Florida

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.3%
- Median rent: $1,086
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 12,951 (20.4%) of all housing units.

Canva

#22. Gainesville, Florida

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.3%
- Median rent: $1,052
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 51,825 (40.2%) of all housing units.

Tricia Daniel // Shutterstock

#21. College Station, Texas

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.3%
- Median rent: $1,003
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 46,371 (47.7%) of all housing units.

Canva

#20. State College, Pennsylvania

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.4%
- Median rent: $1,043
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 21,325 (36.9%) of all housing units.

Wendy van Overstreet // Shutterstock

#19. Athens, Ohio

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.4%
- Median rent: $840
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 9,004 (40.2%) of all housing units.

Canva

#18. Stillwater, Oklahoma

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 35.9%
- Median rent: $827
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 14,745 (47.3%) of all housing units.

Lewis Liu // Shutterstock

#17. Ithaca, New York

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.0%
- Median rent: $1,218
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 19,641 (45.8%) of all housing units.

Canva

#16. Edwards, Colorado

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.1%
- Median rent: $1,724
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 5,627 (28.8%) of all housing units.

JNix // Shutterstock

#15. Troy, Alabama

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.1%
- Median rent: $705
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 4,404 (38.3%) of all housing units.

Canva

#14. Ocean City, New Jersey

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.6%
- Median rent: $1,197
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 9,153 (21.8%) of all housing units.

Sean Pavone // Shutterstock

#13. Miami

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.8%
- Median rent: $1,492
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 901,224 (40.1%) of all housing units.

ACCESS A NEW KIND OF MIAMI RENTAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT

Access a full-service Miami rental property management team with more than 40 years of real estate industry experience in the area.

Canva

#12. Bloomington, Indiana

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.8%
- Median rent: $980
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 27,619 (42.1%) of all housing units.

Canva

#11. Huntsville, Texas

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 36.9%
- Median rent: $917
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 11,081 (46.6%) of all housing units.

Nick Vendetta // Shutterstock

#10. Vineland, New Jersey

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 37.1%
- Median rent: $1,131
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 17,549 (33.8%) of all housing units.

Canva

#9. Corvallis, Oregon

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 37.2%
- Median rent: $1,201
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 16,532 (44.2%) of all housing units.

Sabrina Janelle Gordon // Shutterstock

#8. Natchitoches, Louisiana

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 37.2%
- Median rent: $746
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 6,690 (48.6%) of all housing units.

Canva

#7. Truckee, California

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 37.4%
- Median rent: $1,380
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 10,072 (24.6%) of all housing units.

Canva

#6. Eureka, California

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 37.4%
- Median rent: $1,079
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 22,798 (42.4%) of all housing units.

DISCOVER RELIABLE RENTAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT IN CA

Discover a reliable San Francisco rental property management team that can guarantee your rental income and provide 24/7 support.

Peter Titmuss // Shutterstock

#5. The Villages, Florida

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 38.8%
- Median rent: $1,055
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 7,940 (12.9%) of all housing units.

Canva

#4. Pullman, Washington

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 40.9%
- Median rent: $887
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 10,010 (55.6%) of all housing units.

COMPREHENSIVE RENTAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT IN SEATTLE

Learn more about how our Seattle rental property management team can help you get rental payments on time every time.

Canva

#3. Starkville, Mississippi

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 41.6%
- Median rent: $807
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 11,409 (45.7%) of all housing units.

Canva

#2. Boone, North Carolina

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 42.8%
- Median rent: $948
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 7,835 (37.7%) of all housing units.

Sabrina Janelle Gordon // Shutterstock

#1. Minden, Louisiana

- Median gross rent as a percentage of household income: 44.6%
- Median rent: $701
- Number of renter-occupied homes: 5,112 (34.5%) of all housing units.

Data reporting by Elena Cox. Story editing by Jeff Inglis. Copy editing by Tim Bruns.